Thursday, December 21, 2006

 

Happenstance

The next book to get checked off my list isn't really a book at all. It's an online novel written (and suggested) by a good friend of the Mattress Police, Vanessa V. Kilmer (aka "Nessa", aka "Goldennib"), who has several blogs, the main one being The Chrysalis Stage. Her novel is called Happenstance.

Nessa had to surmount an even greater handicap than adolescent naivete: She wrote her novel in 30 days, as part of National Novel Writing Month. I'm not going to lie and tell you that you can't tell it was written in a hurry, because you can. But I think I can honestly say that it's a more engaging story than the blockbuster bestseller (and now feature film!) Eragon.

It really wouldn't be fair to hold this novel to the same standards as the other books on my list. Nessa obviously wrote it as a lark, just to say that she had written a novel. And writing 50,000+ coherent words in a month is an accomplishment in itself. I'm sure she's well aware of the flaws of the novel (her Dorothy Parker quote at the top of the page indicates the level of reverence she attaches to her work).

The story takes place in a small Celtic community called Deepshade in northern Europe on the outskirts of the Roman Empire. The protagonist is a young woman named Alena, whose beloved husband has died and who must now find a husband within a year or face losing her position and considerable holdings within the village. Something like a Dark Ages version of The Bachelorette results, with the villagers summoning elegible bachelors from surrounding areas. Various adventures and amusing confrontations ensue.

Nessa obviously knows something about the historical basis of her setting; Despite her obviously hurried writing, Deepshade and its people are convincingly real. To contrast with Eragon again, I could tell that Nessa has thought out her world beyond the reaches of her narrative. Whereas the world of Eragon feels like a cardboard cutout, Alena's environment feels like a real place. There are occasional lapses into modern idioms and I wondered at some points if these barely civilized villages were really comprised of people as progressive in their viewpoints as Alena and her friends. Still, I bought the premise, I could visualize Deepshade, and I came to really like Alena as a character.

So my verdict is: Not half bad. There is a lot of filler. I mean a lot of filler. There is an almost completely unrelated story-within-the-story that goes on for like 3 chapters, and even the sub-story is padded with excruciating detail. It's also a little hard to follow at first, there are some awkwardly handled transitions in point of view, and the ending is rather abrupt. But Nessa obviously has some skill and some real feeling for her characters, locations, and their history. I think that if she removed the unnecessary filler (or replaced it with more relevant subplots) and and did some retooling of some of the prose, she'd have a pretty decent novel on her hands.

Way to go, Nessa!


Comments:
I don't see what is so great about 'Eragon' actually. Shall check out 'Happenstance' when I have time.
 
I found Happenstance to be rather amusing ... I read it the night she released it. I'm a huge fan of random novels with substories and subplots (John Irving's The World According to Garp is my favorite book ever, and is filled with somewhat unrelated substories).

Sometimes books that are approached with a sense of humor (and no intent to make money) are the most fun to read. I have friends who have written books for fun then tried to get them published (a few succeeding). The first drafts are always a hoot to read, but by the final revision they're comparatively dull.
 
Diesel: Thank you so much for taking the time to read my first complete literary baby.

I appreciate your comments and will use them as I attempt the next step in the process, Editing. I will also use your comments when I try to actually plan a novel. Your words give me heart. Thanks.

Anita: I thank you for your comments, too. And I thank you also for taking the time to read.
 
Miao - I don't either. If you're going to read one of the two, I'd definitely go with Happenstance.

Anita - Yeah, I didn't think I liked Garp that much when I read it about 12 years ago, but it really sticks with you. It has a weird unpredictability that is very endearing.

Goldennib - You're welcome. I wasn't sure what to expect, but I was pleasantly surprised. I think the key element of your writing is honesty -- it doesn't feel like you're trying to pull one over on the reader. After reading a manufactured work like Eragon, that's much appreciated.
 
My goodness Diesel, with all the mileage you got off Eragon, a children's book written by a teenager, I can't wait to see what you do with the grown up books on your list! (Practicing my sarcasm, how'm I doin?...)
 
Post a Comment



Links to this post:

Create a Link



<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Subscribe to Posts [Atom]